Skip to content


Parashat Toledot 5787 – 11/14/2026

Parashat Toledot 5787 – 11/14/2026

Beginning with Bereishit 5781 (17 October 2020) we embarked on a new format. We will be considering Rambam’s (Maimonides’) great philosophical work Moreh Nevukim (Guide for the Perplexed) in the light of the knowledge of Vedic Science as expounded by Maharishi Mahesh Yogi. The individual essays will therefore not necessarily have anything to do with the weekly Torah portion, although certainly there will be plenty of references to the Torah, the rest of the Bible, and to the Rabbinic literature. For Bereishit we described the project. The next four parshiyyot, Noach through Chayei Sarah, laid out a foundational understanding of Vedic Science, to the degree I am capable of doing so. Beginning with Toledot we started examining Moreh Nevukim.  The text we are working from is the two-volume translation by Prof. Shlomo Pines, University of Chicago Press, 1963.

Bereshit 25:19-28:9

Rambam continues his dialog with Aristotle. We are at the point where everyone seems to agree that the material of the earthly realm and the material from which the heavens are made are fundamentally different from one another. We have not come to any conclusion about what might have caused this differentiation. Rambam writes:

You already know Aristotle’s demonstration that from the difference of acts the difference of forms may be inferred. Consequently, inasmuch as the motions of the four elements are rectilinear [RAR: air and fire move up, earth and water move down, to their “natural” places] and the motion of the sphere is circular [RAR: the heavenly bodies appear to circle the earth] , it is known that the matter of these elements is not the matter of the sphere. And this is correct according to natural speculation [RAR i.e. “natural philosophy,” or what we call today “science.”] .

He goes on to ask:

Accordingly the following question should be put to him [RAR: to Aristotle], and it should be said to him: Inasmuch as the matter in question is common to all the heavenly spheres and, on the other hand, since every substratum in them has been particularized so as to receive a certain form other than the forms received by the others, who is it that has particularized these substrata and has predisposed them to receive various forms? Is there beyond the sphere something else to which this particularization can be attributed except Gd, May He be cherished and exalted?

Aha! Rambam has shown his cards. If there is differentiation, there must be some principle behind it. But if there is some principle behind the creation, then creation cannot be eternal, or at least it had to begin at some time (I don’t think we can rule out its continuing eternally). And this idea of creation in time implies that there must be a Creator who is transcendental to the creation and Himself eternal and possessed of a Will to create.

Now we have already discussed that in Rambam’s thought and in modern physics, time is not an unbroken line that stretches to infinity on both ends. In physics, time is part of creation – “before” the Big Bang there was no space or time, so we can project backwards in time to the Big Bang, but we can’t say that the universe was created in time, because there was no time before the universe was created, there was only Being. And perhaps out of that being many universes are continually being created, each with its own time and space and no link between them. This is something that objective science can neither prove nor disprove, unless we find an actual connection between these universes. Perhaps on the level of the transcendent, out of which all these universes come, we can find a connection. This is all speculation of course.

Now Rambam twists the knife a little bit:

Here I shall call your attention to the depth of Aristotle’s penetration and to his extraordinary apprehension and to the extent to which this objection undoubtedly pressed hard upon him so that he wished to escape from it by recourse to means in which the nature of that which exists did not help him. Even though he does not mention this objection, it appears from what he says that he wished to bring order for our benefit into the being of the spheres, as he has brought order for us into the existence of that which is beneath the sphere. He wished to do this in order that the whole should exist in virtue of natural necessity and not in virtue of the purpose of one who purposes according to his will whatever it be and the particularization of one who particularizes in whatever way he likes.

Aristotle needs to show that the structure of the cosmos is determined by immutable natural law, which excludes the will of someone or some thing organizing the system according to some purpose that they have. This would, of course, obviate the need for a Gd Who created that universe according to His Will.

I might point out that this argument is exactly the one made by many a contemporary scientist. They argue that the laws of nature operate blindly, and in some sense amorally (doesn’t matter how saintly you are, if you step off a cliff you will plunge downward). There is no overarching purpose to life, and, their unstated conclusion, no absolute moral basis for any code of conduct – in other words, no restraints on individual action. When pressed on how one can organize a society on this basis, someone making this argument will come up with answers like, “Don’t hurt others,” without defining what actions might be hurtful to others. Obviously though, any code of conduct, however simplified, implies that people have free will, and by implication, Gd has free will, if you believe in Gd. Free will is incompatible with a clockwork universe of natural necessity, and free will is necessary for moral responsibility. This is why the defense, “I was just following orders” didn’t fly at Nuremberg.

My understanding of the concept of the laws of nature in Vedic Science is this. The basic laws of nature are the most fundamental modes of vibration of Pure Consciousness within itself. These fundamental vibrations then ramify into the various forms and phenomena we see, and this ramification is also governed by laws of nature. However, Maharishi also describes Pure Consciousness as a “field of all possibilities,” and therefore the particular path by which creation ramifies from its origin is not fixed – in fact, virtually any kind of universe is possible. Apparently, the path of evolution today is contingent on the particular path it took yesterday and the day before. The great paleontologist and Yankee fan Stephen J Gould explored the idea of contingent evolution in the 1980’s and 90’s, and the idea has itself evolved since then.

The upshot of this argument is that even if life is governed by immutable natural laws, the actual path that that evolution takes can vary wildly from one “experiment” to the next. In other words, the existence of laws of nature, regularities in nature, does not mean that everything we see is there of “natural necessity,” as Aristotle wishes to prove.

We will look further at Rambam’s critique of Aristotle’s arguments next week, Gd willing.

**************************************

Commentary by Steve Sufian

Parashat Toledot

“Toledot” means “generations, descendants.”  More basic than the literal meaning is the meaning “stages of evolution.”  We will look at this parshah from this point of view.

The parshah begins with “and these are the generations of Isaac” and tells the story of Isaac’s sons, Jacob and Esau from whom generations will be born, and of Gd’s promise to Isaac that if Isaac will follow Gd, as did Isaac’s father Abraham, then his descendants will be multiplied “like the stars of the heavens” and the land and all nations will be blessed by Isaac’s descendants. “Heaven” symbolizes “Wholeness” and “stars” symbolize the details of Wholeness, the details through which Heaven sends its grace to human and all beings. Similarly, “land” symbolizes “Wholeness” and “nations” symbolizes the details of Wholeness.

On the surface of this parshah, we see competition, deception, favoritism: Isaac and Rebecca do not seem to have been good parents, skilled and effective in raising two sons to be whole, complete.

It’s common to say that Esau, “a man of the fields,” symbolizes the outer field of life, the physical, while Jacob, “a quiet person, sitting in tents,” symbolizes the inner field of life, the spiritual.

Often people see a battle taking place between these two people and these two aspects of life, but life, to be Life, needs to have both physical and spiritual and they need to be integrated.

­A great blessing came to me in understanding a step in how this integration takes place when I heard someone giving a quote from Maharishi Mahesh Yogi, founder of the Transcendental Mediation Program ®.

Maharishi commented that Ananda, Total Joy (in Hebrew: Simchah), is everyone’s birthright.

Looking at the story of Jacob asking Esau to sell him his birthright for some porridge he was making, it occurred to me that Jacob, symbolizing the Spiritual aspect of Life, was asking Esau, symbolizing the Physical aspect of Life, to end his famished state by surrendering his commitment to the Physical Alone, and opening himself to the spiritual porridge Jacob was cooking.

Porridge seems to have a bubbly quality to it and cooking it seems to me to be equivalent to revealing that Ananda/Joy/Unified Field/Sameach/Gd, has a texture: it is not just flat, it has a bubbly quality.

So rather than Jacob cheating Esau, acting cruelly, Jacob was actually enlivening the Joy in Esau, ending his famishment, by taking from him his false birthright in the Physical, and giving him his real birthright, in Ananda, Gd.

Similarly, when Toledot tells us that Esau, the man of the fields, was Isaac’s favorite we can see that Isaac was unable to integrate the spiritual with the physical and so he was not able to live with Wholeness, the integration of the spiritual and the material. We can see this very clearly when Toledot also tells us that Isaac became blind: what greater blindness than to be unaware of Wholeness.

For Rebecca to deceive Isaac by dressing Jacob so that he seemed like the hairy Esau might seem like favoritism on Rebecca’s part, but Esau had already sold his physical birthright to Jacob and so what Rebecca was doing was creating an integration of spirituality with materiality, an integration that would raise the generations to increasingly higher levels of integration.

Later in Torah we see a very high step in this integration and Restoration of Awareness to Jacob’s descendants when at Mt. Sinai, all of the nation of Israel hears Gd speak, something that I have not seen reported in any other scripture, amazingly enough.

Still, hearing Gd speak from a distance is an experience of the duality between Gd and humanity: Full Restoration of Awareness means going beyond this duality and experiencing the Oneness which is All.

Toledot reminds us that we need to live balanced, integrated lives, making sure that our material needs are nourished by our spiritual development so that we go beyond duality of any kind and experience duality and all multiplicity within the Oneness that is our real Nature: The All-in-All.

Reading, reciting, hearing, discussing Torah, the Siddur (prayer book) and their supplements and commentaries and acting with their Wisdom is an excellent way to do this. Getting together with our community, with our World Family, is an excellent way to do this; both are excellent ways to increase our Joy and Wholeness by sharing, by integrating the multiplicity of life so that we experience the Wholeness with its details.

Let’s continue easily, gently, innocently doing this.

Baruch HaShem